Hot Water Heater Replacement Cost Factors

Spread the love

Water heaters are essential appliances that heat water in your home. These appliances are essential for your home to work as it should. It is not an option to have one at all.

However, these water heaters don’t last forever. They should be replaced. You can save money by switching the type of water heater you have when you replace them.

What is a Water Heater?

Hot Water Heaters are tanks that heat water and maintain a constant temperature. You can also store water in them so that you have an emergency supply. Your home probably has a water heater.

The size of the water heater that you need will depend on how big your home is and how large your family. If you have hot water, you will definitely need one. A boiler is the only alternative, which is less common in private homes.

Does Your Water Heater Need to Be Replaced?

Does Your Water Heater Need To Be ReplacedView in gallery

There are many signs that your hot water heater needs to be replaced. These signs may not always be consistent, but a plumber can diagnose the problem immediately if they are present.

Cold Water

This is a telltale sign that your hot water heater isn’t working. You should replace your hot water heater if your water is not heating up as well as it used. It might not be storing enough water, or not heating it.

Even if your water is not cold but warm, it could be a hot water issue. It is best to wait for hot water to cool down before you check if hot water is present. This will let you know if the hot water heater is not heating or holding water.

High Utility Bills

If your water and electric bills are higher than usual and you don’t know why then it may be your hot water heater. Problems with your hot water heater can impact both your electric and water bills.

People will use more water if the water heater isn’t heating up fast enough. If there is a leak, you will use more water. Water heaters are usually powered by electricity.

Older Than 10 Years

Even if you don’t have problems, water heaters usually start to fail after about ten years. While most heaters won’t experience problems for 15 to 20 years, ten is the minimum age at which they can start to fail.

So pay attention to any issues and get them fixed as soon as possible. You can prolong the life of your water heater and put off buying a new one.


If there are unexpected leaks coming from the water heater closet or if the water heater itself is leaking, then it needs to be repaired or replaced. This can cause water to be wasted, which is not energy-efficient and environmentally harmful. Have someone come to inspect the heater immediately to determine if it needs to be replaced. It may just need a 15-minute patch, but a professional should still do that for safety reasons.


If you hear weird noises coming from your water heater then it needs to be checked. It’s important to have your water heater checked, even if strange noises are heard when you turn on the water.

Noise are signs that you cannot see. These can be minor or major problems that need to be addressed immediately.

Water Tastes Different

If your water tastes different, then go ahead and have the heater and pipes checked. Water can taste strange for many reasons, but if your water tastes rusty it could be due to the heater.

If your water heater has been in use for a while, it could be something else. If your water heater has been around for a while, it’s likely that something is wrong with it.

Water Heater Replacement Cost

Water Heater Replacement CostView in gallery

Replacing a water heater can be quite pricey in certain circumstances. The average cost is around $1000, which isn’t all that bad considering the huge difference that it can make. It’s the price range that matters most.

You may pay as little as $500 for a replacement if you have a small, simple heater. If you have more serious problems, however, you may end up paying thousands of dollars for a replacement.

What is the Water Heater Replacement Price?

The cost of replacing your water heater depends on several factors. These are the factors that will impact the final cost to replace your hot water heater. To get a better idea of the cost, you can check them out.


Your geographical location affects the cost of your hot water heater. It is impossible to determine how much your location affects the cost of your hot water heater without consulting a local contractor. Costs fluctuate with supply and demand and other factors.


There are many different sizes for hot water heaters. The 40-gallon tank is the most common size, which should be under $1000. Those under 40 can cost as little as $200 while those larger can cost up to $4000.

Tank Or Tankless

This is a huge decision. There are two types of water heaters: tank-style and tankless. A tank water heater stores hot water in a tank and will hold somewhere between 30 to 80 gallons. This accounts for more than 90% of all water heaters in the USA.

Tankless heaters are twice as expensive than tank water heaters. Although they provide endless hot water, they are much more difficult to maintain than tank heaters.


There are multiple types of contractors that you may need to replace your water heater. Plumbers are the most common type. The electrician is the second. The third is the worker who will frame it. Most of the time all three are required. Plumbers will charge around $80-$100 an hour, electricians will charge around the same, and general contractors will charge somewhere between $30 and $80 an hour.


Permits aren’t needed for every job, but you usually need to get one in order to work on a hot water heater. A permit will usually cost you a few hundred dollars, but prices can vary depending on where you live and what the local laws are.

You can either call to get your permit yourself or hire a contractor who will do it for you. This will add to the cost of your project. It is much easier to have a contractor get a permit than for homeowners.

Water Or Gas

There are many different ways to power a hot water heater. Converting from one to another can be costly. You usually won’t pay more than $1000 for this job but that’s on top of what you are already paying.

Heater Placement

Where you place the hot water heater matters a lot. You will need to run water lines to your appliances, sinks and other water supplies. This is something to consider when you place your hot water heater.

The closer something is to a heater, the more water it will use and how hotter the water. The water must flow along the pipes in order to reach the heater. It is also important to determine if the area is above or below the hot-water heater.


You will be charged for every material used for your hot water heater. For wood framing and pipes for piping as well as the hot water heater, you will be charged. You’ll likely pay more if you don’t purchase the materials yourself.

It’s better to hire contractors to buy the materials, as they will know what to order. It is more wasteful to purchase something you don’t need than to spend extra on something you do.

Types Of Water Heaters

Types Of Water HeatersView in gallery

The type of water heater you have depends on the type of fuel it uses. There are now many different fuel types than ever before. These are the most common fuels for water heaters today.


Gas and propane water heaters are a common choice and alternative to electric-powered water heaters. Although they are more costly initially, they are often cheaper and more suitable for winter power outages or off-the grid.


Electric water heaters are cheaper at first but cost more in the long run. These are the most common choice for water heaters as they don’t require much more. If you use electricity, it will not.

It usually costs $1000 to $2000 but can cost less in some cases. If you require a lot of hot water quickly, this is not a good option.


Heat pump water heaters cost a little more than electric water heaters but not by much. They are very efficient and use a heat pump to draw heat from the environment and then transfer it to the water. They don’t require much energy and can even recycle heat. These are great options, but they can be quite expensive. For small homes, the larger panels will cost you far more and won’t save you any money over time.


Trying to go greener with solar panel companies? You are in luck. These solar-powered water heaters have become increasingly popular. The average cost for a solar water heater is between $1,500 to $5,000. But this is only an average. It can actually cost over $10,000 to get started, which is usually what deters people from using them. This will hopefully become the norm in the future and the prices will drop significantly.

Emily Medlock,
Read More

Leave a Reply