Scroll Saw VS Band Saw: What’s the Difference?

Spread the love

Christmas might be right here earlier than you already know it and also you wish to make delicate tree decorations as items. Or possibly you’ve been wanting to construct a customized wooden bench on your entrance yard and have determined now’s the time. Figuring out that you just want a scroll noticed or a band noticed is simple however figuring out which one you want generally is a little trickier.

Scroll Saw VS Band Saw

On this article we are going to evaluate the two, reviewing their options, specs, and what each is meant for. We’ll even add in our suggestion of fashions to contemplate. So, carry on studying to find which noticed might be proper for the initiatives you wish to create.

What’s a Scroll Saw?

Named after its conventional use of creating scrollwork, the scroll noticed is used for small initiatives with detailed work and infrequently intricate designs. It delivers the accuracy of a small, handheld blade, with the pace and energy of an electrical noticed. Scroll saws are typically used for wooden, however can even lower by way of plastic, plexiglass, and a few very skinny metals. Along with intricate and detailed designs, a scroll noticed can also be an ideal software for making inside cuts in these similar supplies.

A scroll noticed has a comparatively small worktable and makes use of quick, skinny blades that transfer in an up and down movement at extraordinarily excessive speeds. They’re powered by electrical energy and their pace is usually managed both by a pedal or a variable pace knob. The desk can tilt and lock in place permitting you to chop bevels at numerous angles and a specifically designed foot holds your work safely and securely to the noticed.

The throat of a talent noticed is the distance between its blade and the rear half or neck of the noticed. This distance dictates the dimension of fabric you’ll be able to work with and customarily ranges from twelve- to thirty inches. Whereas slicing, the blade will attain as much as the heart of the materials and you may then flip the materials the wrong way up and work with the blade on the different facet. Because of this in case your scroll noticed has a twelve-inch throat, your materials could be as much as twenty-four inches.

Blades for a scroll noticed are simple to vary and can be found in numerous widths. They arrive in two sorts known as plain-end or pin-end. Due to the manner the blades work, solely slicing on the downward stroke, they can not lower materials thicker than two inches and ideally mustn’t lower materials multiple inch thick except specified to take action. The stress on the blades could be simply adjusted with simply the flip of a knob.

What’s a Band Saw?

What is a Band Saw

In distinction to scroll saws and different forms of saws you may need in your arsenal, band saws are usually used for larger woodworking initiatives and may deal with a lot thicker materials. They’ve extra energy than a scroll noticed and supply extra versatility as nicely.

A band noticed has a worktable just like the scroll saws, however it’s open in the back and front letting you narrow lengthy items with no obstruction.

As its identify suggests, the blades of a band noticed are lengthy, steady, metallic bands that stretch between two and generally 4 wheels. Most fashions are two-wheeled with one wheel above the slicing desk and one beneath. The blade cuts in a continuing downward movement because it loops repeatedly round the wheels. There are quite a few blade choices together with smaller blades for extra detailed work and larger, stronger blades for thicker initiatives. And though band saws are typically used for woodworking, with the proper blade, they will even lower by way of metallic.

Scroll Saws Versus Band Saws

Scroll Saw VS Band Saw

Blade Pace

A scroll noticed’s blade pace is measured in strokes per minute and ranges from 400 to 1800 SPM. The pace is managed by a foot pedal or a variable-speed knob. The noticed’s potential to make tight turns and complex designs are primarily based on the TPI or tooth per inch of the blades themselves. The upper the TPI, the quicker and tighter the blade can flip.

A band noticed’s pace is measured in ft per minute and is usually round 3000 FPM. Some fashions supply the potential to run at a secondary, decrease pace that’s often between 1000 to 1500 FPM. The slower pace is best fitted to slicing non-ferrous metals and different denser supplies.

Blade Size

Scroll noticed blades are available 5 and six-inch lengths and both plain-end or pin-end kinds.

The band noticed blades are available numerous lengths starting from fifty-two to 261-inches and the size listed in the proprietor’s guide is usually a median between the shortest and longest blades the machine can deal with. Most fashions can accommodate a spread of blade lengths.

Blade Dimension/Width

Scroll noticed blades are typically sized from #2 to #12 and are primarily based on TPI. Greater numbered blades have fewer TPI and are higher for a thicker and tougher materials. They aren’t in a position to lower tight, intricate corners. Decrease numbered blades have the next TPI and are the ones you need when elevated precision is required.

Band noticed blades vary in widths from 1/8 of an inch to at least one inch and may lower radiuses from 3/16 of an inch to 7-inches relying on dimension. Wider blades can stand up to slicing pressure however are usually not good for tighter diameters. Narrower blades are higher fitted to lighter extra delicate work.

Weight

Scroll saws typically vary from 5 to sixty kilos making them comparatively moveable.

Band saws on the different hand could be upwards of 250 kilos and are higher for stationary placement.

When to Use Every

Scroll saws are ideally suited instruments for small initiatives with skinny materials. Some examples embrace intricate wooden ornaments, DIY jigsaw puzzles, or slicing letters and numbers from wooden or plastic.

Band saws can deal with bigger initiatives and thicker supplies. They’re nice for initiatives together with tabletops, hanging cabinets, and picket patio furnishings.

The WEN 3959T 2.5-Amp, 9-inch Benchtop Band Saw

The WEN 3959T 2.5-Amp, 9-inch Benchtop Band SawView in gallery

The WEN 3959T Band Saw makes use of 59 ½-inch blades ranging in widths from 1/8 to three/8 of an inch, permitting this machine to make intricate or heavier-duty cuts. The noticed has a 2.5-amp electrical motor that rotates the blade at as much as 2500 FPM and the ball-bearing design makes for the easy operation of the blade.

This mannequin can lower as much as 3 ½-inches deep and as much as 9 inches huge. The spacious worktable could be angled as much as 45°, permitting you to chop exact bevels safely and precisely.

The equipment features a miter gauge, a 2 ½-inch built-in mud port, a rip fence for aligning straight cuts, an adjustable blade guard, a ¼-inch blade, and a two-year restricted producer’s guarantee.

Product specs:

Producer WEN
Producer’s Mannequin Quantity 3959T
Weight 40 Kilos
Dimensions 19 x 14.1 x 29 Inches
Color Black
Model 2021 Mannequin
Energy Supply Corded Electrical
Motor 2.5 Amp
Guarantee 2-Yr

Execs:

  • Light-weight
  • Moveable
  • In a position to accommodate intricate turns.
  • In a position to lower materials as much as 3 ½-inches thick.
  • Entry to expert service technicians.

Cons:

  • Gentle obligation functions solely.

WEN 3921 – 120 Volt, 16-Inch, Two-Path Variable Pace Scroll Saw

WEN 3921 – 120 Volt, 16-Inch, Two-Direction Variable Speed Scroll SawView in gallery

The WEN 3921 Scroll Saw accommodates each pinned and pin-less blades and its distinctive design permits you to set the blade in one among two instructions – commonplace or at 90°. With simply the flip of the blade, you’re not restricted to the noticed’s sixteen-inch throat and may accommodate items at any width. And with the detachable pin-less blade holder you could be positive the blade will keep securely in place whereas working. When it’s time for a blade change, the thumbscrew adapter makes the tool-free course of easy and fast.

When the pin is in the commonplace place, this mannequin’s 9/16-inch stroke can lower wooden as much as two inches thick with a throat depth of sixteen inches. And with a easy flip of a knob, the stroke pace could be adjusted from 550 to 1600 strokes per minute (SPM).

The worktable has a sixteen-inch slicing depth and could be angled as much as 45° for crisp, correct bevels. The hold-down foot ensures your venture is at all times securely in place and the built-in worm work mild offers you the flexibility to light up your work space from any angle or place.

An adjustable air pump regularly clears particles as you narrow, and the 1 ½-inch mud port retains your work floor clear. A forged iron base holds the noticed firmly in place and built-in storage retains all the pieces in a single handy place.

Product specs:

Producer WEN
Producer’s Mannequin Quantity 3921
Weight 27.5 Kilos
Dimensions 26.38 x 13 x 14.75 Inches
Color Black
Model Scroll Model
Energy Supply Corded Electrical
Motor 120 Volts, 144 Watts
Guarantee 2-Yr

Execs:

  • Light-weight
  • Moveable
  • Two-direction slicing.
  • In a position to lower materials as much as two inches thick.
  • Versatile work mild.
  • Entry to expert service technicians.

Cons:

  • Gentle obligation functions solely.

Conclusion

Scroll saws and band saws might look related however they’ve fairly completely different capabilities making it necessary to know their options and what every does earlier than buying one on your venture. Keep in mind, a scroll noticed is what you’ll want once you wish to create smaller, extra delicate objects. For larger objects with a thicker and tougher materials, a band noticed’s energy and pace will ship the cuts you’re after.

We’d love to listen to from you! Tell us if this text was useful and you probably have any questions associated to the objects we’ve mentioned.

Read More

Leave a Reply